Why this is hard to judge from the outside
Most agents will tell you what you want to hear in the listing presentation, because that's how they win the listing. The honesty shows up later, after the home is on the market and showings aren't converting to offers. By then you've lost weeks. The better approach is to ask questions upfront that reveal how an agent actually operates, not just what they promise.
Questions worth asking any agent
- Will you walk the home with me in person before we talk price, or are you pricing it from your desk?
- What happens if your advice and my expectations don't match?
- How often will I hear from you, and in what form?
- Will I see every offer in writing, with the numbers spelled out?
- Is there a point in the listing where we sit down and reassess if things aren't moving?
An agent who hesitates on any of these, or gives vague answers, is telling you something.
How price and condition actually get decided
No agent should hand you a number on the spot without doing the work. A real answer on price comes from looking at the home itself: condition, updates, location within the neighborhood, and what's closed and what's currently competing for the same buyers. Condition affects price more than most sellers expect, and an agent who skips past it to get to a number isn't doing you a favor. David Cohn's approach is to tour the home in person before giving any read on price. That includes pointing out things that might cost you money or buyer interest, even when it's not the easy conversation. The analysis comes after the walkthrough, not before it.
What a written process looks like
One way to know an agent will be straight with you after you sign is to ask if their process is written down. David Cohn uses a written, 61-action process across 8 phases for sellers. Parts of it that matter here:
- A written update every Monday, including weeks where nothing happened. You're not left guessing.
- A same-day response to every showing request, so you know interest levels in real time, not after the fact.
- Every offer presented in writing with a net sheet, so you see the real numbers, not a verbal summary.
- A scheduled Day 14 review built into the process specifically to look honestly at what's working and what needs to change.
That last point matters most for your question. A lot of agents avoid the hard conversation about price or condition until a seller forces it. Having it scheduled in advance means it happens whether or not it's comfortable.
Red flags to watch for
- An agent who gives you a listing price before seeing the home.
- Promises about how fast it will sell or what it will appraise for.
- Vague answers about how often you'll hear from them.
- No mention of how offers will be communicated to you.
- Reluctance to point out anything negative about the home during the first walkthrough.
Where David Cohn fits in
David has lived in Jupiter for 15 years and spent about 30 years before real estate running his family's retail and eCommerce business, which shows up in how he handles negotiation and detail work. He's a solo agent, which means the person who tours your home is the same person managing your file start to finish. If you want a straight read on your home's condition and what it means for price, the simplest next step is to have David walk the property with you. No number gets attached until that happens, and nothing about the walkthrough is designed to make you feel good, it's designed to be accurate. You can reach David directly at 561-299-1520 or book a time at luxlivingsouthflorida.com/meeting/844771395512691/david_cohn.